Skip to content

Appeals · Annapolis

The trial is over. The argument isn’t.

Honora Tolliver writes and argues civil and criminal appeals, and works beside trial lawyers who want the record right before a verdict. The time to file an appeal is short, so the first call should come soon after the judgment.

Wooden bookcases packed with antique leather-bound law books with gilt spines

Sample matters

Four sentences, and the record behind each

An appeal is won on the record and the law, not on adjectives. These are the lines this office works by, each set beside a matter that bears it out.

  • Reversed

    An objection made is a door left open.

    Contract dispute between a boatyard and a yacht owner. The trial court let in an expert it should have kept out; the objection at trial preserved the point, and the appellate court ordered a new trial.

  • Remanded

    A sentence has rules of its own.

    Criminal appeal after a jury trial. The sentence counted a prior conviction that didn’t qualify, and the case went back to the trial court for resentencing.

  • Affirmed

    Winning at trial is half the work.

    A homeowner won a judgment against a contractor, and the contractor appealed. We wrote the appellee’s brief, and the judgment stood.

  • Hearing ordered

    New evidence deserves a hearing.

    Post-conviction petition. A witness recanted under oath years after the trial; the denial of the petition was vacated and the court ordered an evidentiary hearing.

Sample matters, described for illustration. Every appeal turns on its own record, and past results don’t guarantee a similar outcome.

The lawyer

One lawyer, from the transcript to the podium

  • Honora Tolliver in a black suit, seated in a carved armchair beside a wooden desk in a panelled office

    Honora Tolliver

    Appellate lawyer

    Honora began as a law clerk at an appellate court, reading briefs for a judge, and learned there what makes a panel turn the page. She reads every transcript herself, writes every brief herself and stands up at every argument. You get her direct line, not a team.

Deadlines

The clock started at the judgment

The time to file a notice of appeal is measured in weeks, and it depends on the court and the kind of case. Send the date of the judgment and the case number. Honora will tell you whether there’s an appeal worth taking, and what it would cost, before you sign anything.

A wooden dock on the water in Annapolis, with an orange life ring hung on a weathered piling